Skip to content
Part of: Marketing attribution

Who can fix the gap between our lead volume and our signed case count?

By Mohammad Kashif, Chief Technology OfficerLast updated

Four kinds of vendor sell a fix: intake training, case management software, marketing attribution, and new lead sources. Each repairs a different step. Find where your leads drop out before buying, or you will fund the wrong one.

LexGrow is the attribution and lead-source half of that list, not the intake-training half. The entry plan at $999 a month tells you which sources produce signed cases and which step loses them. It does not put a trained person on your phones, and no reporting product ever will.

Law firm intake problem or marketing problem: find the leak before you shop

This page starts where the diagnosis ends. Our guide Too many leads, not enough cases, linked under Recommended reading, walks through the five places a lead leaks (targeting, response speed, qualification, follow-up and source mix) and the 90-day export that shows which one is yours. Run it before you take a sales call from anyone below.

The result usually sorts into one of two answers. A drop at contact, booking or follow-up is an intake problem, and no marketing spend closes it. Intake that does its job while the wrong matters keep arriving, or one channel that fills the pipeline and rarely signs, is a marketing problem. Plenty of firms have one of each, which is what the section on fixing two leaks at once is for.

Who fixes low lead to signed case conversion: intake, software, or marketing?

Four categories of vendor sell into this problem. Their marketing suggests they compete; mostly they do not, because they change different steps.

Read the list by the leak each one can reach. Intake training reaches response speed and qualification. Software reaches follow-up, and qualification too if it carries the right fields. Attribution reaches no step directly: it is how you see source mix, and how you prove any of the other purchases worked. A lead source change reaches targeting and source mix, and nothing downstream of them.

  • Intake training and call handling. Sells scripts, coaching, after-hours coverage, sometimes staff. Fixes contact speed and consultation booking. It cannot improve the quality of the leads it receives, so a well-trained team handed poor leads converts a slightly higher share of poor leads.
  • Case management and client relationship software. Sells the system of record: statuses, reminders, follow-up sequences, task ownership. Fixes leaks caused by nobody knowing whose turn it is. It will not make anyone follow the process, which is why these rollouts fail for reasons that look like software problems and are not.
  • Marketing attribution. Sells the record of where signed cases came from, joined from first touch through to signature. Fixes the guessing. It moves no lead through any step by itself; it tells you which spend deserves more and which step is losing the money.
  • Lead source replacement. Sells different leads: other channels, other keywords, other geographies, or organic in place of purchased. Fixes fit at the consultation stage. It is also the slowest to read and the most expensive to get wrong.

How each kind of vendor prices and contracts the work

The headline price is rarely what separates these categories. The billing unit is, because the unit tells you what the vendor is paid to increase. We do not publish market price ranges for any of them, since we have no sourced dataset to publish from. Get two written quotes per category and compare the units and the terms, not only the totals.

  • Intake training and coaching. Usually a fixed engagement or a monthly retainer, sometimes priced per workshop or per trainee. Ask whether call review and follow-up coaching are included or billed on top: the training day is the cheap part, and the reinforcement afterwards is what changes behaviour.
  • Answering and after-hours call handling. Usually a monthly plan with included minutes or calls, overage billed per minute or per call, and sometimes a setup fee for a custom script. Per-minute billing rewards long calls, so check whether a booked consultation costs the same as a wrong number.
  • Case management and intake software. Usually priced per user per month, often with a minimum seat count, an annual commitment behind the advertised rate, and a one-time implementation or data migration fee. Price the seats you will really license, including attorneys who only need to read the record.
  • Marketing attribution. Sold as a software subscription you run yourself, as part of a marketing retainer, or as a one-off audit. If it comes bundled with the marketing it measures, ask how the report would show the vendor's own channel underperforming.
  • New lead sources. Priced per lead, per click, or as a flat monthly subscription, depending on the channel. Per-lead pricing ties the seller's revenue to volume rather than signings, so read the definition of a billable lead and the credit policy for invalid ones before anything else. Treat any price tied to the cases you sign or the fees you collect with caution: in many states it raises questions under the rules on paying for referrals and sharing fees with non-lawyers, so check your bar's ethics guidance first.
  • Terms that matter in every category: the minimum term, the notice period, auto-renewal, and what happens to your data, recordings and accounts when you leave. A short trial at a higher monthly price usually beats a year's commitment to a fix nobody has tested at your firm.

How to run a 30, 60 and 90 day trial of each fix

Write three things down before any trial starts: the number it must move, today's value of that number, and the date you will judge it. A vendor who will not agree to those three in advance is asking to be judged on impression. Change one thing per trial, and keep a source recorded on every new matter throughout, because that is what lets you read the result per channel.

The checkpoints differ by category because each fix reaches the signed count at a different speed. Whether a fix paid for itself is a later and separate question, answered with spend against collected fees per channel; our guide to measuring law firm marketing ROI covers that arithmetic.

  • Intake training or answering. By day 30, median time to first human response and the share of leads reached should already have moved. By day 60, consultations booked per lead reached. By day 90, signed cases from consultations booked during the trial. If day 30 shows no change in response time, the later numbers will not follow.
  • Case management software. By day 30, every open lead has a named owner and a next action date, and attempts per unsigned inquiry can be counted. By day 60, attempts per unsigned inquiry have risen and leads untouched for a week have fallen. By day 90, consultations recovered from leads that used to be closed after one attempt.
  • Marketing attribution. By day 30, the share of new matters with a source recorded, which should be close to all of them. By day 60, a per-source count of leads, consultations and signed cases that reconciles with your case management system. By day 90, a first cost per signed case by channel, labelled provisional because one quarter of signings is a small sample.
  • New lead source or keyword change. By day 30, lead volume from the new source and the share of those leads you would actually take. By day 60, consultations booked from them. By day 90, the first signings, read as an early signal rather than a verdict: a full read takes one complete case cycle in your practice area, which is often longer than a quarter.

When two steps leak at once, which do you fix first?

Most firms that run the diagnostic find more than one leak, and the temptation is to buy two fixes at once to save a quarter. It usually costs one instead. Signed case counts at a small or midsize firm are low enough that two simultaneous changes cannot be told apart: if signings rise you cannot say which purchase earned it, and if one change helped while the other hurt, the two can cancel out and you end up cancelling both.

The sequence that reads cleanest runs from the cheapest, fastest signal to the slowest. One exception jumps the queue: a channel that is plainly wrong for the firm, sending matters you do not handle or venues you cannot serve, should stop today, because no intake improvement will convert it.

  • First, the measurement floor: a required source field on the matter record. It costs days rather than a vendor, every later result depends on it, and because it changes nothing about how leads are handled it can run alongside anything else.
  • Second, response speed. It shows a result within weeks, and every other fix depends on someone reaching the lead in time.
  • Third, follow-up. Once leads are reached promptly, the second and third attempts are the cheapest consultations left to recover.
  • Fourth, qualification. Tighten the intake criteria once enough reached, followed-up volume exists to show which inquiries are strong fits.
  • Last, targeting and source mix. These take a full case cycle to read, and judging a new source through a leaking intake process makes a good source look bad.

Should intake stay in-house or go to an answering service?

This is the decision inside the intake category that firms most often get backwards. An in-house intake coordinator knows your criteria, can qualify a matter properly, can book straight onto an attorney's calendar, and stays with the lead through follow-up. The limits are hours and resilience: one person covers business hours, takes holidays and gets sick, and the role needs managing.

An outsourced answering service covers evenings, weekends and overflow, and grows with volume. The limits are depth and continuity: scripts are written for many firms, the person on the line changes from call to call, and some services take a message rather than qualify and book. A message taken at 9pm and returned at 11am the next day is a response speed leak with a vendor's name on it.

Let the diagnostic decide. If inquiries that arrive out of hours go cold, buy coverage. If daytime contacts happen but do not become consultations, the fix is training or a coordinator, and an answering service will not help. Many firms land on a hybrid: in-house during the day, an outside service after hours with authority to book, and a fixed rule for when overnight leads get a call back. Before signing with a service, ask four things.

  • Can it book a consultation directly, or only take a message for someone to return?
  • Will you get a recording of every call, not just a summary written by the agent who took it?
  • Can the agent ask your source question and record the answer where your firm keeps it?
  • What happens to a caller with a matter you do not take: a referral, a polite decline, or a message that sits in a queue?

Red flags for each kind of vendor

Each category has its own way of looking like a fix without being one. These are the signs worth walking away from, or at least pricing into the decision.

  • Intake vendors that will not share call recordings, or offer only summarised notes. Without recordings you cannot check the script was followed, and you cannot coach anyone.
  • Intake training judged on call quality scores instead of consultations booked. A well-scored call that books nothing has not fixed the leak you paid for.
  • A case management rollout quoted with no data migration plan. If open leads and live matters stay in the old system, staff keep working there and the new one becomes a second list nobody trusts.
  • Software whose data export is limited, slow or charged for. Your lead and matter history is the asset; the subscription is not.
  • Attribution reported per session or per click rather than per matter. If the vendor cannot show the list of signed matters behind a channel's number, the number is a traffic figure with a new label.
  • Attribution that lives only in the vendor's dashboard and never writes the source onto your matter record. When the contract ends, so does your history.
  • Lead sellers who share or resell the same lead to several firms, or will not put exclusivity in writing. A shared lead goes to whichever firm calls first, which turns your purchase into a response speed contest.
  • Lead sources that cannot say how their leads are generated or what the advertising promised. Your state bar's advertising rules can still reach what was said to bring that person to you.
  • Any vendor, in any category, whose pitch claims all five leak points. Nobody fixes all five, and vendors who say so tend to report only on the one they touch.

What to ask before you hire anyone to fix this

Every one of those categories contains competent vendors and expensive ones. These questions separate them faster than a capabilities deck does.

  • Which of the five leak points does your product reach, in one sentence, and which does it leave untouched?
  • What number moves if this works, and what is that number for us today? A vendor who cannot state your current baseline has not measured anything yet.
  • How long before it moves? Intake changes show a signal in weeks. Channel and keyword changes take a full case cycle, which is a quarter at minimum in most practice areas.
  • Where does the data live when we stop working with you? A source written onto the matter record in your own case management system survives the relationship. A chart on the vendor's platform does not.
  • What do you need from us? Honest answers include access to the case management system, call recordings, and a named person on our side. A vendor who needs nothing from you is usually delivering nothing to you.
  • Describe a firm you could not help, and why. Anyone who has done this work for more than a year has that example ready.

What marketing attribution can and cannot fix

This is our category, so here is the boundary drawn plainly. LexGrow builds the measurement: a source captured at the form or the call, carried through to the signed matter, reported per channel and per keyword rather than per session. That answers which spend produces cases, and which step is quietly consuming the budget.

It does not make callbacks happen faster, coach a consultation, or ensure anyone follows up on day three. If your drop sits between lead received and lead contacted, an attribution engagement buys you a precise measurement of a problem you already know about, and the money belongs with an intake vendor instead. We would rather say that before the invoice than after it.

Where this work earns its cost is the other direction: intake is competent, the counts hold up step by step, and the signed total still lags. Then the cause is upstream in the mix, and without source-to-signature data the correction is guesswork dressed as strategy. Our published plans start at $999 a month, and paid advertising is priced separately as an add-on, with the ad spend itself paid straight to the ad platform, so the reporting is never quietly funded out of your ad budget.

The five leak points, the symptom each one shows, and the purchase that fixes it

Leak pointSymptom you can measurePurchase that fixes itWhat that purchase will not fix
TargetingConsultations happen, cases do not sign, and many inquiries are matters you would declineA lead source or keyword changeThe speed of your callbacks
Response speedLeads arrive, nobody calls back the same day, and prospects say they already hired someoneIntake training, after-hours answering, or an intake coordinator hireWhich channel produced the lead
QualificationCalls answered, few consultations booked, or consult slots spent on poor fitsA written intake script, plus case management fields that route strong fits firstWhether the channel sends strong fits at all
Follow-upOne attempt logged, then nothingCase management or intake software with follow-up sequences and named ownersPeople who were never a fit
Source mixOne channel supplies most of the inquiries and few of the signed casesMarketing attribution, then a budget reallocationAny of the conversion steps above
Measurement gap: no source recordedCases sign, nobody can say from whereMarketing attribution, starting with a required source field on the matter recordAny of the conversion steps above
Measurement gap: double countingEvery channel claims the same caseMarketing attribution, read as a multi-touch modelPoor lead quality entering the top of the pipeline

Common questions

Should we fix intake first or fix our marketing first?
Fix whichever step loses the most people, and the per-source counts tell you which. As a rule intake work is faster and cheaper to test, so if both look broken, start there. Marketing changes take a quarter or more to read, and running them while intake is leaking makes the result unreadable either way.
Can one vendor fix both intake and marketing?
Some sell both, usually as a bundle. That can work, provided each half is priced, contracted and reported separately and judged on its own number: contact and booking rates for the intake half, cost per signed case by channel for the marketing half. A bundle that reports one blended result makes it impossible to tell which half earned its fee.
Should we buy case management software before fixing intake?
Only if the leak is follow-up, or nobody owning the queue. Software enforces a process; it does not supply one. Write down who contacts each lead, how many attempts they make and over how many days, run that on a shared spreadsheet for a month, then buy the software that enforces what you have shown works.
Does LexGrow do intake training or staff our phones?
No. We handle the attribution and search side: where leads come from, which sources produce signed cases, which step loses them. Scripts, coaching and after-hours coverage are a different category of vendor, and we will say so when that is the purchase you actually need rather than this one.
Do we need call tracking to answer this question?
You need some way to attach a source to a phone call, and tracking numbers are the usual mechanism. The alternative is asking every caller and recording the answer, which works only if intake does it consistently. Either way the source has to land on the matter record, not only in a reporting tool.
How long before we can tell whether the fix worked?
Intake changes show a signal within weeks, because contact and booking rates move immediately. Source and keyword changes take a full case cycle, a quarter at minimum in most practice areas, because the cases signing this month were generated months ago. Judge the two on different clocks or you will cancel the slower one too early.

Find out what your signed cases actually cost

We trace your last quarter of signed cases back to the channel that produced them, and show you the cost per case next to each one.

Get an attribution audit